For me and a lot of people, this was a huge movie and is therefore a huge movie to be reviewing. This picture represents the culmination of my generation's greatest and favorite story and that kind of influence is not to be taken lightly. For everyone, Deathly Hallows had to be awesome. Going in with that in mind may have been a bad idea as it made my expectations ridiculously high. I think I'll have to see the film again to form a clearer opinion. I'll try my best to sort everything out regardless. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows part 1 did some things right and some things wrong. Its greatest strengths were by far the acting and directing. The main three characters delivered excellent and believable performances in a movie that was emotional tense and at many times quite moving. And many of the supporting cast (particularly Ryhs Ifans as Xenophilius Lovegood, Toby Jones as Dobby, and the various actors comprising the Malfoy family) also delivered performances that added a lot to the movie. Direction of the movie was also great. The forest chase, parts of the sky battle, and everything in Godric's Hollow had me enthralled. Not to mention the desolate and beautiful landscapes that added so much to the middle of the film. This paired with some excellent cinematography gave it a very grey and very isolated and alone feel. The movie and the characters and the world as a whole seemed to feel hopeless. For effects, this movie was also sewn up pretty well. The style of dueling that was executed so well in the fifth and sixth movies was presented well again in this one. The more pronounced role of apparation in this movie was also handled with visual excellence (the escape from the ministry and splinching come to mind). There was also the addition of an animated sequence that fit pretty well with the theme of The Tales of Beedle The Bard and was visually intriguing if not fully fitting with the movie in its entirety. Throughout the movie there were a number of little things that I picked up on that I did really enjoy. The scene where the locket is destroyed was done far better than I could have expected it to be. The scenes involving snatchers were also well done. What I enjoyed most about this movie was that it kept inline with the book very well and also that it did not hang itself up on explaining what was going on to the viewer. The filmmakers knew that if you're a Harry Potter fan you should be able to understand the subtle elements and ideas of the series (i.e. the two way mirror). This was what I had the most hope for while waiting for the release of the movie. That by dividing the book into two films essentially a 4-6 hour film, they could make a movie that would make fans proud. In this respect HP7 did not disappoint. I did however feel that there were a few weaknesses of the film. Most notably for me was the score. While I don't deny that Alexandre Desplat wrote a beautiful score and that he is a great musician, for the most part I just didn't feel that the music really fit. In a lot of ways this soundtrack reminded me of the scores of the first two films as well as elements of the fourth. While the second score was probably my favorite of the whole series (the 6th is close too) the Deathly Hallows score seemed to fit this film just as much as the Chamber of Secrets score would have (that's saying not terribly well). It had too much of a romanticized lightness throughout that I didn't feel was appropriate for many of the more intense scenes and themes of the film. That's not to say it didn't have its moments. The Obliviation and Farewell to Dobby gave me goosebumps and themes like Snape to Malfoy Manor and Godric's Hollow Graveyard did have some great elements that I hope will be brought back in the next film. Similarly to the score, I just didn't get the exact feel that I would have liked from this movie. What it came down to for me was that this movie just didn't have the sense of gravity and importance that it really should have. This is a quest to destroy the fragments of the most evil soul to ever live. A battle for the very fate of the world mixed with a side story involving the greatest triad of magical objects in history. It didn't seem like this movie took itself seriously enough. I would have liked to see more from the outside world and the state of chaos and disorder it was in, even though I do completely understand and will not debate that the story is and should be primarily about Harry, Ron, and Hermione. I think in a lot of ways the absence of a really deep score did make this discrepancy more pronounced to me. All in all I really did enjoy this movie. I wouldn't say it was my favorite of the series but it was certainly among the top. I am now more than ever looking forward to the sequel and final chapter of the Harry Potter saga. Hopefully I will get the chance to see this movie again and clear up some final thoughts. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows part 1 receives an 8.5/10.
Thursday, November 25, 2010
Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 1
For me and a lot of people, this was a huge movie and is therefore a huge movie to be reviewing. This picture represents the culmination of my generation's greatest and favorite story and that kind of influence is not to be taken lightly. For everyone, Deathly Hallows had to be awesome. Going in with that in mind may have been a bad idea as it made my expectations ridiculously high. I think I'll have to see the film again to form a clearer opinion. I'll try my best to sort everything out regardless. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows part 1 did some things right and some things wrong. Its greatest strengths were by far the acting and directing. The main three characters delivered excellent and believable performances in a movie that was emotional tense and at many times quite moving. And many of the supporting cast (particularly Ryhs Ifans as Xenophilius Lovegood, Toby Jones as Dobby, and the various actors comprising the Malfoy family) also delivered performances that added a lot to the movie. Direction of the movie was also great. The forest chase, parts of the sky battle, and everything in Godric's Hollow had me enthralled. Not to mention the desolate and beautiful landscapes that added so much to the middle of the film. This paired with some excellent cinematography gave it a very grey and very isolated and alone feel. The movie and the characters and the world as a whole seemed to feel hopeless. For effects, this movie was also sewn up pretty well. The style of dueling that was executed so well in the fifth and sixth movies was presented well again in this one. The more pronounced role of apparation in this movie was also handled with visual excellence (the escape from the ministry and splinching come to mind). There was also the addition of an animated sequence that fit pretty well with the theme of The Tales of Beedle The Bard and was visually intriguing if not fully fitting with the movie in its entirety. Throughout the movie there were a number of little things that I picked up on that I did really enjoy. The scene where the locket is destroyed was done far better than I could have expected it to be. The scenes involving snatchers were also well done. What I enjoyed most about this movie was that it kept inline with the book very well and also that it did not hang itself up on explaining what was going on to the viewer. The filmmakers knew that if you're a Harry Potter fan you should be able to understand the subtle elements and ideas of the series (i.e. the two way mirror). This was what I had the most hope for while waiting for the release of the movie. That by dividing the book into two films essentially a 4-6 hour film, they could make a movie that would make fans proud. In this respect HP7 did not disappoint. I did however feel that there were a few weaknesses of the film. Most notably for me was the score. While I don't deny that Alexandre Desplat wrote a beautiful score and that he is a great musician, for the most part I just didn't feel that the music really fit. In a lot of ways this soundtrack reminded me of the scores of the first two films as well as elements of the fourth. While the second score was probably my favorite of the whole series (the 6th is close too) the Deathly Hallows score seemed to fit this film just as much as the Chamber of Secrets score would have (that's saying not terribly well). It had too much of a romanticized lightness throughout that I didn't feel was appropriate for many of the more intense scenes and themes of the film. That's not to say it didn't have its moments. The Obliviation and Farewell to Dobby gave me goosebumps and themes like Snape to Malfoy Manor and Godric's Hollow Graveyard did have some great elements that I hope will be brought back in the next film. Similarly to the score, I just didn't get the exact feel that I would have liked from this movie. What it came down to for me was that this movie just didn't have the sense of gravity and importance that it really should have. This is a quest to destroy the fragments of the most evil soul to ever live. A battle for the very fate of the world mixed with a side story involving the greatest triad of magical objects in history. It didn't seem like this movie took itself seriously enough. I would have liked to see more from the outside world and the state of chaos and disorder it was in, even though I do completely understand and will not debate that the story is and should be primarily about Harry, Ron, and Hermione. I think in a lot of ways the absence of a really deep score did make this discrepancy more pronounced to me. All in all I really did enjoy this movie. I wouldn't say it was my favorite of the series but it was certainly among the top. I am now more than ever looking forward to the sequel and final chapter of the Harry Potter saga. Hopefully I will get the chance to see this movie again and clear up some final thoughts. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows part 1 receives an 8.5/10.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment